As both a physical therapist and CrossFit coach, one of the most common questions I hear is, "Should I push through this, or take time off?" The answer isn't always simple, but I'm going to bust some myths and give you practical guidelines to make this decision easier and smarter.
Common Misconceptions About Pain and Training
First, let's bust some myths that I frequently hear in my practice:
Misconception #1: "No Pain, No Gain"
This outdated mindset has led to countless preventable injuries. While training should be challenging, pain is your body's warning system. There's a huge difference between the burn of muscle fatigue and the sharp pain of injury. Challenge yourself, but learn to recognize when your body needs modification or rest.
Misconception #2: "If I Rest, I'll Lose All My Progress"
Taking a few days to modify your training won't erase your gains. In fact, strategic rest or modification often leads to better long-term progress than training through pain. Many athletes come back stronger after a short, smart break (that includes accessory work and training around the injury) versus pushing through and forcing a longer recovery period.
Misconception #3: "I Should Stop All Activity If Something Hurts"
Complete rest isn't the answer. Often, modified movement helps recovery better than total inactivity. The key is finding the right level of activity that promotes healing without aggravating the issue. This is where guidance from a PT can be invaluable.
Misconception #4: "It'll Go Away On Its Own"
Minor discomfort might resolve itself, but recurring issues usually indicate an underlying problem. Ignoring these warning signs often leads to compensatory movements that can cause problems elsewhere in your body. Early intervention can prevent a small issue from becoming a chronic problem.
Misconception #5: "I Only Need to See a PT When I'm Injured"
Physical therapists are movement experts who can help prevent injuries before they happen. Regular movement assessments can identify potential problems and help you address them before they affect your training or activities of daily living.
Now for some practical guidelines…
The Smart Athlete's Pain Guide
Now let's establish what we mean by "discomfort" versus "pain." Think of it like a traffic light system:
Green Light: Safe to Train
- Muscle soreness that improves as you warm up
- Mild stiffness that dissipates within the first 10 minutes
- General fatigue that doesn't affect your form
- Minor discomfort that doesn't change your movement patterns
Yellow Light: Modify Your Training
- Discomfort that alters your movement patterns
- Pain that persists or worsens during your warm-up
- Soreness that doesn't improve with movement
- Sharp twinges that come and go
- Discomfort that stays at the same intensity throughout your workout
Red Light: Time to Seek Help
- Sharp pain during specific movements
- Pain that persists after your workout
- Discomfort that's getting worse over time
- Pain that keeps you awake at night
- Any sensation accompanied by swelling or limited range of motion
- Symptoms like dizziness, headache, or nausea following neck discomfort
Real-World Examples
Let's look at some common scenarios I see in the clinic:
Scenario 1: Post-Workout Shoulder Soreness
Sarah* came in worried about shoulder soreness after some high volume snatches. We determined it was normal muscle fatigue because:
- The discomfort improved with warm-up
- She had full, relatively pain free range of motion
- No sharp or pinching sensations
- Strength remained consistent
Scenario 2: Knee Pain During Squats
Mike* tried pushing through knee pain for weeks. He required treatment and some exercise modifications because:
- The pain was changing his squat form
- Discomfort increased during his workout
- The pain began affecting his daily activities like going up and down stairs
*names changed for patient privacy
Smart Training Modifications
When you're in the "Yellow Light" zone, here's how to modify effectively (preferably with help from your PT, trainer, or coach):
1. Scale the Movement:
- Reduce the weight
- Decrease the range of motion
- Modify the movement pattern
2. Adjust the Volume:
- Reduce the number of reps
- Break sets into smaller chunks
- Increase rest periods
3. Focus on Other Areas:
- Work on skill development
- Train unaffected body parts
- Prioritize mobility work
Prevention Is Better Than Recovery
The best way to avoid the "should I train?" dilemma is to prevent issues before they start:
- Perform proper warm-ups (every time!)
- Scale workouts appropriately
- Maintain good sleep and nutrition
- Include recovery days in your programming
- Address minor issues before they become major ones
When to Contact a Physical Therapist
Don't wait until you're in constant pain to seek help. Schedule an assessment if:
- You're consistently modifying workouts due to discomfort
- You're unsure about the source of your pain
- Your performance is declining
- You're avoiding certain movements
- You've had the same nagging issue for more than two weeks
- You’re activities of daily living are starting to be affected
The Bottom Line
Learning to distinguish between productive training discomfort and warning signs is crucial for long-term fitness success. Remember: the goal isn't to avoid all discomfort, but to train intelligently and sustainably.
Want personalized guidance? Schedule an assessment to identify potential issues BEFORE they impact your training or performance of essential daily tasks.
Comments